Read Sheila Connolly Books In Order : Every Fan MUST Know!

By Kathy | Last Updated on March 27, 2026

Note: This page contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases when you click on the link, but you are not charged extra.

Sheila Connolly is a well-established author known for weaving compelling mysteries and intricate characters into her novels. With a deep understanding of human nature, Connolly has captivated readers with her various series, ranging from cozy mysteries to historical thrillers. In this article, we’ll take a deep dive into the world of Sheila Connolly’s books, exploring the background of her work, explaining the recommended reading order for her series, discussing what makes her novels stand out, and considering whether reading her books in order is necessary for the full experience. By the end, you’ll have a comprehensive understanding of her works, so you can decide whether her books are right for your next literary adventure.

List Of Sheila Connolly Books In Order

More On Sheila Connolly Books In Chronological Order

1. Still Life with Murder (2005)

Okay, so this is the first book in the ’Museum Mystery’ series, and it’s a great one! You meet the wonderful curator, Nell Pratt, who’s thrust into solving a crime when an elderly museum benefactor is found dead. As if her life isn’t complicated enough, she’s got to juggle keeping the museum’s collections intact and figuring out whodunnit, all while navigating the sometimes messy world of museum politics. It’s the perfect cozy mystery if you love a mix of history, art, and intrigue.

2. The Scent of Murder (2006)

In the second book of the ’Museum Mystery’ series, Nell Pratt is back, and this time she’s dealing with a murder that happens at a museum gala! A renowned perfumer is found dead, and naturally, Nell is pulled into the investigation. There’s drama in the air (literally, thanks to those fragrances), and Nell’s got to balance the delicate art of diplomacy with solving a crime. Can she figure out who did it before the museum’s reputation goes down the drain? It’s a delightful mix of mystery and luxury!

3. The Grapes of Murder (2007)

Now we’re talking! This book takes us to the world of wine and a winery museum where Nell Pratt gets entangled in a case about a missing heir and a suspicious death. A body is found in the wine cellar, and Nell, being her usual curious self, just can’t stay out of it. This is one of those books where you get both a rich history lesson and a spine-tingling mystery. It’s full of great atmosphere, and if you love a good glass of wine (or just the history behind it), this one’s for you!

4. Fire Engine Dead (2008)

Okay, buckle up because this one is a ride! Nell Pratt is dealing with a firehouse museum now, and she’s just gotten used to the idea of preserving history when a murder shakes things up. The victim’s death is tied to a long-forgotten firehouse scandal, and as Nell dives deeper into the past, she uncovers more than she bargained for. The mix of modern-day detective work and historical research is spot-on in this one, and you can practically feel the heat of the firehouse in the air!

5. The Wrong Girl (2009)

Alright, this book takes a little detour from the museum world and introduces us to Maura Donovan, a young woman who inherits a pub in Ireland. It’s a whole new setting, but Sheila Connolly’s cozy mystery skills are just as sharp as ever. Maura’s not only adjusting to her new life in a foreign country, but she’s also got to deal with some shady happenings in her new pub. Throw in a bit of Irish charm and a murder mystery, and you’ve got yourself a page-turner!

6. Scandal in Skibbereen (2010)

In the second ’County Cork’ mystery, Maura Donovan is back in Skibbereen, Ireland, and things are getting even more complicated. After discovering a shocking family secret, Maura’s life gets turned upside down again. A local woman is murdered, and of course, Maura’s caught up in the investigation. It’s full of twists, small-town gossip, and that unmistakable Irish atmosphere that makes you feel like you’ve been transported right into the middle of it all.

7. Hannah’s Secret (2011)

Okay, now we’re diving into the world of genealogical mysteries with the ’Museum Mystery’ series, but with a new twist. This one’s focused on a historical figure, and it’s about uncovering the secrets of the past. Hannah, a museum curator, uncovers a personal mystery while diving into a genealogical search. Old letters, family connections, and a modern-day mystery all combine to make this book impossible to put down. If you love a mix of personal history with a dash of whodunnit, you’re going to love it!

8. Death at the Emerald City (2013)

This book introduces a new setting again, this time revolving around a historic theater. This is the first book in the ’Victorian Village’ series, and it’s like stepping into a different time period altogether. A historical society is trying to preserve a Victorian-era theater, but when a dead body is discovered, the society’s work becomes more about finding a killer than preserving the past. The rich history, quirky characters, and period detail make this one a treat for fans of historical mysteries.

9. A Fatal Winter (2014)

In this book, you’re diving deeper into the Victorian village mystery series with an intriguing murder that happens during the dead of winter. What starts as a simple case of a missing person quickly turns into something more sinister as secrets about the town’s past start bubbling up. The winter atmosphere adds to the tension, and the characters are lovable and engaging. It’s a fantastic read if you’re in the mood for a mystery set in a rich, historical setting.

10. Once She Was Mine (2017)

This is another change of pace for Sheila Connolly. The story centers around a family trying to deal with a centuries-old mystery that intertwines with their present. It’s all about family secrets, personal identity, and unearthing old grudges. The suspense builds slowly, and it’s got just the right touch of emotion. If you’re looking for something a little deeper and reflective while still packing that signature Connolly mystery punch, this one delivers.

Background On Sheila Connolly Books

Sheila Connolly is an American author whose career spans multiple genres, but she’s especially beloved for her cozy mystery series. Her books often combine the charm of small-town life with the intrigue of a good whodunit, making them perfect for readers who enjoy stories with light-hearted yet intriguing plots. Connolly’s knack for creating rich, immersive settings and characters with depth and personality has made her a favorite among fans of the genre.

Connolly’s writing is widely recognized for its clever plotting and engaging prose, making her books easy to read and addictive. Her cozy mysteries often feature a strong female protagonist, typically an amateur sleuth who gets drawn into a series of puzzling and sometimes dangerous events. Connolly’s writing is also notable for its local color and sense of place-whether it’s a small historical town, a farm in the countryside, or a local orchard, the setting itself often becomes an essential part of the story. Her attention to detail gives readers a chance to feel like they are right there alongside the characters, experiencing the mystery unfold firsthand.

Over the years, Connolly has written a variety of series that have earned her a dedicated following. Among her most popular works are the "Museum Mystery" series, the "County Cork" series, and the "Orchard Mystery" series. Each series brings a unique flavor to the cozy mystery genre, but all share Connolly’s signature style-strong storytelling, well-drawn characters, and a captivating mystery at the core of the narrative.

Reading Order Explained

While Connolly’s books can be enjoyed individually, many readers prefer to read them in the order they were published to fully appreciate the character development and narrative arcs that span across multiple books. Some series have recurring characters and evolving plots that are easier to follow if read sequentially. Here, we’ll break down the best reading order for some of Connolly’s most beloved series.

1. The Museum Mystery Series

   The Museum Mystery series revolves around the protagonist, Nell Pratt, who works as a museum curator in Philadelphia. The series explores the inner workings of museums and historical artifacts, all while presenting intriguing mysteries that need solving. The best reading order for this series is:

   • Fundraising the Dead (Book 1)
   • Silent Night, Deadly Night (Book 2)
   • The Body in the Attic (Book 3)
   • The Body in the Library (Book 4)
   • The Body in the Birches (Book 5)

   Each of these books builds on the last, with Nell’s personal and professional life evolving as she unravels each new mystery.

2. The County Cork Series

   Set in Ireland, the County Cork series follows Maura Donovan, an American woman who inherits a pub in a small Irish village. This series offers a great blend of cozy mystery and travel, with its picturesque Irish backdrop. The best reading order here would be:

   • Buried in a Bog (Book 1)
   • Scandal in Skibbereen (Book 2)
   • An Early Wake (Book 3)
   • The Likeness (Book 4)

   Maura’s transformation from a fish-out-of-water character to someone who truly belongs in her new community is one of the compelling aspects of this series, and it’s best experienced from the beginning.

3. The Orchard Mystery Series

   This series focuses on the world of apple orchards, blending mystery with agriculture. The series is centered around the protagonist, Meg, who finds herself in the middle of mysterious events surrounding her family’s apple orchard in New England. The suggested reading order is:

   • Rotten to the Core (Book 1)
   • One Bad Apple (Book 2)
   • Apple of My Eye (Book 3)

   The small-town atmosphere and rural setting make this series especially charming, and the central mystery of each book is intricately woven into the backdrop of orchard life.

What I Like About The Series?

One of the things that draws me to Sheila Connolly’s books is the consistent warmth that radiates from her stories. Her characters feel like people you could meet in real life, and their growth over the course of each series adds a satisfying layer of depth. The mysteries themselves are never overly complex or grim, but they are always engaging enough to keep you turning the pages.

Connolly’s ability to create a strong sense of place is another standout feature. Whether it’s a cozy museum in Philadelphia, a historic Irish village, or a rural apple orchard, the settings in her books almost become characters in their own right. The way she describes these places is rich and vivid, allowing the reader to fully immerse themselves in the world of the story.

Another aspect I appreciate is Connolly’s talent for keeping her mysteries grounded in real life. The motives for crime are often personal or connected to the characters’ histories, rather than being driven by abstract or fantastical reasons. This makes the mysteries feel more relatable and accessible, which is a big part of why they’re so enjoyable to read.

Finally, the pacing in Connolly’s books is superb. The plot unfolds at a steady pace, with plenty of twists and turns to keep you engaged without overwhelming you. The writing is accessible, so even readers new to the cozy mystery genre can jump in without feeling lost.

Should You Read Sheila Connolly Books In Order?

While it’s possible to enjoy Connolly’s books as standalone novels, reading them in order does offer a deeper and more satisfying experience. For instance, many of her series feature character development and arcs that are spread out across multiple books, so reading them sequentially helps you understand the relationships between characters, their backstories, and their personal growth.

In particular, if you’re diving into a series like the Museum Mystery or County Cork series, reading in order ensures that you don’t miss out on important developments, such as character relationships, evolving plot lines, and the protagonist’s personal challenges. Some of her books even reference previous events that are explored in earlier novels, so following the reading order can help you avoid spoilers or confusion.

That said, if you’re looking for a quick read or just want to sample a particular book, many of Connolly’s works can still be enjoyed without needing to start at the very beginning. However, for the most rewarding experience, I recommend reading the books in the order in which they were published.